Buy vs. Build: an Easy Software Framework

Buy vs. Build Overview

Many of our clients have learned the hard way that building custom software consumes significant time, money, and resources—only to later turn to external solutions. With business departments now managing their own IT functions, aligning technology with business needs has become more important than ever.

‍

Forbes highlights how tech departments often prioritize flashy dashboards to showcase data-driven insights to executives. However, the process behind these visuals is often inefficient, requiring late nights, inconvenient data manipulation, and necessary analysis. 

‍

The question of whether to build software in-house or rely on third-party vendors is more tense, as budgets come under scrutiny and internal teams get stretched after waves of layoffs. I'm going to explain now the pros and cons of buying and building software. But first, organizations must evaluate several key dimensions:

• Cost to Build: This includes the initial development investment, ongoing maintenance expenses, and necessary infrastructure. Both short-term and long-term costs should be considered.
• Cost to Maintain: The continued expenses for updates, security, and user support.
• Cost to Buy: The upfront licensing fees, recurring subscription costs, and integration efforts.
• Core Expertise: The technical skills needed to develop and sustain the solution. Some systems follow standard software development practices, while others demand deep domain expertise and an understanding of industry trends.
• Business Criticality & Market Maturity: Whether the system is vital to core operations and if well-established solutions already exist in the market.

‍

Using this framework, organizations can systematically assess whether building or buying is the right choice. Now, let’s dive into the pros and cons of each approach.

‍

Buying Software

‍

Purchasing software means acquiring pre-built solutions designed for a broad user base. These products are developed to meet the general needs of a particular sector or function. Since the software has already been created and tested, businesses can quickly find a solution that fits their needs, pay for it, and start using it right away—eliminating the complexities of in-house development.

‍

Advantages of Buying:

• Faster ROI: Since the software has already been developed, it can be deployed almost immediately, making it ideal for businesses needing immediate solutions.
• Lower Costs: Off-the-shelf software is usually more affordable than custom software since development costs are spread across multiple buyers.
• Feature-Rich & Scalable: Most commercial software solutions come with a wide range of features and built-in scalability to grow with your business needs.
• Dedicated Support: Vendors handle updates, security patches, and technical support, reducing the burden on internal IT teams. Additionally, businesses gain access to the expertise of seasoned software vendors who specialize in maintaining and optimizing these solutions vendors provide updates and customer support, reducing the burden on internal IT teams.
• Reliability & Usability: Established software has been tested extensively and widely used, ensuring stability, security, and a user-friendly experience.

‍

Disadvantages of Buying:

• Limited Customization: Off-the-shelf software may not perfectly align with unique business processes, requiring workarounds or additional integrations. 
• Integration Challenges: Pre-built software may not always integrate seamlessly with your existing tools and platforms, such as ERPs. This can create inefficiencies and require additional customization or middleware solutions.

‍

If an existing software solution meets most business requirements, buying off-the-shelf can save time, resources, and effort—allowing companies to focus on their core operations rather than reinventing the wheel.

‍

Building Software

‍

Building software means developing a custom solution tailored to an organization’s unique needs. Companies often choose this approach when existing software solutions fall short of their requirements. While custom software provides greater control and competitive advantages, it also requires significant investment, technical expertise, and long-term commitment.

‍

Pros of building software:

• Competitive Differentiation: Custom software can provide a competitive edge by offering unique features unavailable in standard solutions.
• Tailored Offering: Businesses have complete control over the design, functionality, and user experience of the software.
• Full Control Over Data & Roadmap: Organizations retain complete ownership of the software’s roadmap and how data is managed.

‍

Cons of building software:

• High Costs: Developing software requires significant financial investment—not just in the initial build but also in ongoing maintenance, security, and infrastructure. A dedicated team of skilled developers, often 50 or more experts, is typically needed to sustain and evolve the system.
• Time-Intensive: Custom software development takes time, delaying the potential benefits and requiring ongoing enhancements.
• Resource Constraints: Maintaining an in-house software development team can be challenging, especially if software development is not the company’s core expertise.
• Higher Risk: Studies indicate that a majority of internal software projects fail to meet expectations due to scope creep, unforeseen challenges, and accumulating technical debt.

‍

‍

Why Finboot’s Marco Track & Trace?

‍

After exploring both options—building vs. buying—the key question remains: which is the best fit for your business? While every company has unique needs, a trusted, adaptable solution can accelerate digital transformation while ensuring long-term stability.

‍

At the beginning, we’ve said that off-the-shelf software often comes with customization and integration challenges, but MARCO Track & Trace is built to overcome these hurdles. It’s highly configurable, adapting to your unique processes while integrating seamlessly with existing systems (including ERP) through API. From supplier portals to digital forms, it collects and verifies supply chain data with accuracy and ease.

‍

With MARCO Track & Trace, you’re not just adopting software—you’re partnering with a team committed to sustainability, digital traceability, and innovation. 

‍

Get in touch to book a demo and learn how we can support your digital transformation.

‍

‍